Lobster F.A.Q. and Cooking Tips


Click on a link to jump down the page to your Answer or scroll down and read as you go.

Please NOTE: Some answers are catered towards LIVE lobsters, if you are using FRESH/FROZEN Lobster tails then you do not have the short time frame in which to cook your Lobster.

 

How to BOIL a Lobster:
Boiling is one of the easiest ways to cook Lobster

To boil lobsters, fill a large kettle with water. Add 2 tablespoons of salt for each quart of water (allowing about 2 quarts of water for each lobster). Bring the water to a boil. Place one live lobster in the pot at a time (head first) and let the water boil again. Cover the kettle and simmer about 15 minutes for each pound of hard-shell lobster. For safety reasons, we recommend you leave the wooden pegs or rubber bands around the claws on, until after they are fully cooked. Be careful not to overcook. This will make the meat a bit rubbery.

NOTE: If you ordered cooked (or pre-cooked) lobster, reduce cooking time to only 5 minutes.

If the lobster is a new-shell lobster (or soft-shell), reduce boiling time by three minutes for each pound.

When meat is white, shells are bright red and 2 front antenna pull out easily, lobsters are ready to serve and eat.

back to top

How to BAKE A Lobster:

Preheat oven to 400 degrees. Place lobsters on back (belly up) and split lobster from head to tail. Remove all internal tracks including sac from the hear area. Place on baking pan (on back). Add stuffing and melted butter to keep moist and bake for 15 minutes at 400 degrees. After 15 minutes, reduce heat to 350 degrees and bake for an additional 10 - 15 minutes. For safety reasons, we recommend you leave the wooden pegs or rubber bands around the claws on, until after they are fully cooked. Be careful not to overcook. This will make the meat a bit rubbery.

NOTE: If you ordered cooked (or pre-cooked) lobster, reduce cooking time to only 5 minutes.

When meat is white, shells are bright red and 2 front antenna pull out easily, lobsters are ready to serve and eat.

back to top

How to STEAM a Lobster:
Steaming is another very easy way to cook a Lobster

Pour about 2 inches water in the bottom of a large kettle. Add 2 tablespoons of salt for each quart of water. Bring the water to a boil. Place live lobsters in one at a time (head first). Cover kettle and let water return to boil. Allow 18 minutes for each pound of hard-shell lobsters.

If the lobster is a new-shell Maine lobster (or soft-shell), reduce boiling time by three minutes for each pound. When the antennae pull out easily and a bright red color is attained, the lobsters are ready to eat. For safety reasons, we recommend you leave the wooden pegs or rubber bands around the claws on, until after they are fully cooked. Be careful not to overcook. This will make the meat a bit rubbery.

NOTE: If you ordered cooked (or pre-cooked) lobster, reduce cooking time to only 5 minutes.

When meat is white, shells are bright red and 2 front antenna pull out easily, lobsters are ready to serve and eat.

 

How soon should you cook a lobster once received?
When a lobster is shipped LIVE, it will have been out of ocean water for about 24 hours. Live lobster is very perishable and will not survive more than a day out of fresh water. Live lobster therefore has a very small room for error and should be cooked as soon as possible after you receive your order. You should always cook lobster live if it was ordered live since it will be raw and subject to normal bacterial growth curves once it expires.

We recommend you cook live lobster no more than 24 hours after you receive them. Once cooked, lobster meat will stay fresh about 3 - 4 days. You can freeze lobster (once cooked) for up to 1 month.

back to top


How can you tell if a lobster is still alive?
You can tell a lobster is still alive if it is moving its legs, tail, claws or antenna. If a lobster flips its tail vigorously, it is still strong and has survived shipping very well. Do not worry if this is not so, they are just a bit weak from shipping & handling. When cooked, if the tail curls and the tail meat is firm, the lobster was live before cooking.

Do not worry about cooking live lobster. Lobsters have nothing more than a primitive central nervous system. There is an easy alternative for cooking live lobster though. Lobsters sleep if placed on their backs. This puts them in a harmless sleep mode (or beta state).

back to top


Is there an alternative way to cook a live lobster?
Yes. Place lobster on sink or counter back down (facing up). Place lobsters in a pot of cold water and set heat on high. As the water heats up, the lobsters will gradually cook while continuing to sleep. Start timing of lobster from the time steam arises (if steaming) or water starts to boil (if boiling). If you're stuffing lobsters, you will need to split the lobsters while they are still alive. But again, they will already be on their backs so they will also be in the sleeping (beta) state.

back to top


Can I put live lobster in my sink or bath tub to keep alive?
NO! YOU SHOULD NEVER EXPOSE A LIVE LOBSTER TO FRESH WATER! The single biggest mistake people make is placing live lobsters in a sink or bathtub. If you do this, the lobsters will die immediately. Salt added to water WILL NOT change this problem. It is better to keep the lobsters cold in the refrigerator in original bags and covered with a damp cloth. But no more that 24 hours of refrigeration is recommended before cooking live lobster. A basic rule-of-thumb for cooking lobster is "the sooner the better".

back to top


How do you travel with live lobster?
If you wish to travel with live lobsters. Place fresh bags of ice directly on top of lobsters in a sealed container. To ensure lobsters are not exposed to fresh melt water, double bag ice in heavy plastic bags. You can use a Styrofoam container or cooler purchased at any grocery store.

back to top


How do you cook lobster?

Basic steaming directions include 2 inches of water in a large enough pot. To boil lobsters, about 2½ quarts will suffice. For boiling, some people recommend using seawater or adding 2 tablespoons of salt to the water to mimic the 3% salt content of the ocean.
For more information, see the top of the page for basic boiling, baking and steaming directions.

back to top


How can you tell when a lobster is cooked?
A lobster is cooked when the 2 front antennae pull out easily, when the meat is white, and when the outer shells are bright red. Never overcook your lobster. Overcooking will tend to make the meat hard and rubbery.

back to top


Aren't lobsters supposed to be red?
Most people think that lobsters are naturally red in color. However, all lobsters are actually a muddy-brown before cooking. Live lobsters are greenish-brown because of many different color pigments (chromatophores). When cooked, all these pigments except for the red (astaxanthin) are hidden.

Due to a rare genetic occurrence, some lobsters are born with blue shells. About 1 in every 30 million sport this blue shell wardrobe. It has even been seen where some lobsters are half blue and half red. Some have even been found to be yellow and orange!

back to top

 

© All Rights Reserved.
This site cannot be reproduced in any way without the express written permission of the Highland Fish Market.
Design, Hosting and Maintenance for this site provided by NetworkLouisville.com

 

 

Highland fish market is located in Louisville, KY ( Kentucky ). Highland Fish Market is the place to go for Fresh Lish in Louisville. Fresh Fish at Highland Fish Market Louisville. Louisville's Fresh Fish Market - Highland Fish Market. Highland Fish Market is not in the Highlands. Highland Fish Market is located on Shelbyville Road in Middletown. Fresh Fish - Highland Fish Market Louisville

Above is a list of links to pages throughout Highland Fish Market. Highland Fish is your Seafood Connection in Louisville, KY. We are located in Middletown, but are within driving distance from these areas: St. Matthews, Chenoweth Square (Shelbyville Road, Frankfort Avenue), The Highlands (Bardstown Road), and Hurstbourne. Middletown is in the East End. St. Matthews (Chenoweth Square, Frankfort Avenue, Shelbyville Road, Hurstbourne are also considered to be in the East End. Bardstown Road is only a mile or two from the East End. Highland Fish Market is Louisville's Connection for Fish and Seafood in Louisville, KY. You want Recipes? We have Recipes! Over 3,100 Fish and Seafood Recipes. We are your Fish and Seafood Recipe Connection in Louisville.

Baked Broiled Grilled Pan Fried / Sauteed Poached Salads Smoked Soups and Chowders Uncooked Deep Fried